MeshDiagnosticsGenerator

Runs a series of diagnostics on the mesh to detect potential issues such as unsupported features

commentnote

This mesh generator currently will only accept serialized meshes. This is most easily accomplished by leaving the mesh type set to replicated. Some of the diagnostics would work as well for distributed meshes, contributions are welcome.

The diagnostics implemented are presented below. The filters and visualization capabilities in Paraview or other visualization software may be leveraged for further diagnostics of mesh issues.

Element volume check

Turn this check on with the "examine_element_volumes" parameter.

A minimum and a maximum element volume can be specified to the MeshDiagnosticsGenerator using the "minimum_element_volumes" and the "maximum_element_volumes" parameters. These diagnostics are mostly used to detect zero or negative volume elements, from distorted meshes.

commentnote:How to fix large elements

Large elements may be sub-divided using the RefineBlockGenerator with for example a "max_element_volume".

commentnote:How to fix negative volume elements

Negative volume elements can be flipped using a MeshRepairGenerator with the "fix_elements_orientation" parameter. This will flip them, making the volume positive, though it may not fix the Jacobian everywhere.

Side planarity check

Turn this check on with the "examine_nonplanar_sides" parameter.

Non-planar elements are generally supported in MOOSE. However, the ray-tracing capabilities treat them approximately at the moment, so it may be useful to examine the mesh before use.

Subdomain element types check

Turn this check on with the "examine_element_types" parameter.

The Exodus output format only supports a single element type (TRI3, QUAD4, HEX8, HEX20, etc) per subdomain. Rather than erroring at the time of output, this diagnostic outputs which subdomains present multiple element types.

commentnote:How to fix subdomains with mixed element types

Subdomains with mixed element types can be split by element type using a MeshRepairGenerator with the "separate_blocks_by_element_types" parameter.

Sideset orientation check

Turn this check on with the "examine_sidesets_orientation" parameter.

Sidesets are oriented. They are represented in MOOSE by a list of elements and sides. Along the boundary, the orientation of these sides should in general be consistent. If it is not, the normal of the sideset is essentially reversed from one side to the next in the sideset.

The sideset orientation check is a heuristic for a common error case. The sideset orientation is only checked for sides that are delimiting two different subdomains. The check makes sure that the order of the subdomains, e.g. which one owns the element and which one owns the element on the other side of the side (the neighbor), does not change throughout the sideset.

Element overlap checks

Turn this check on with the "examine_element_overlap" parameter.

Overlap between elements are generally undesirable. Overlapping elements can be associated with non-conformality and/or breaks in the mesh, which generally are not supported without special numerical treatments, such as using interface kernels or mortar methods. Beyond having disconnected elements, the overlap means the volume of the mesh does not match the physical space volume, raising concerns about accuracy.

We support two heuristics to detect these overlaps:

  • detecting when the centroid of an element is inside another element

  • detecting when a node of an element is inside another element

commentnote

These two checks are heuristics. They can have false negatives if elements overlap but in a way that the centroids and nodes remain outside of other elements. This can happen for example with curved side elements overlapping on a side.

Non-conformality check

Turn this check on with the "examine_non_conformality" parameter.

Non-conformality in MOOSE is generally only supported if it is arising from adaptive mesh refinement created by the underlying mesh library. Additional information about the parent/child relationship between coarse and fine elements is stored at the element level. However, numerous external meshes, especially arising from simulations using adaptive mesh refinement, will present non-conformality. To support them, we usually resort to special numerical treatments, such as mortar methods.

Non-conformality is detected by this diagnostic by looking for nodes that are near an element within a tolerance but not part of this element's nodes.

commentnote

If the non-conformality is extremely minor, and the non-conformal nodes are very close to other nodes, they can be merged together using a MeshRepairGenerator.

Non-conformality arising from Adaptive Mesh Refinement

Turn this check on with the "search_for_adaptivity_nonconformality" parameter.

In the special case of meshes where isotropic adaptive h-refinement was performed, the MeshDiagnosticsGenerator can detect at the interface between coarse and fine elements that the fine elements could be combined into a coarse element. The coarse element, if it were refined with MOOSE h-adaptivity, would be refined into the same fine elements as originally present in the mesh.

This check will only detect mesh refinement for triangle and quadrilateral 2D elements and, tetrahedral and hexahedral 3D elements. For tetrahedra, because the refinement pattern depends on the selection of a diagonal inside the coarse element, the check only considers the tip fine elements on the four vertex of the coarse element.

commentnote

This check is a heuristic. It will only detect adaptive uniform mesh refinement and it will only detect it near interfaces between coarse and fine elements. If the entire mesh is refined the same number of times for each element, it will not be detected.

commentnote

This check may report false positives on some immersed meshes and slit meshes because it will detect non-conformal nodes and will try to examine if the elements next to these nodes can be grouped to form coarser elements.

Elements and sides local Jacobian check

The local Jacobian is checked for positivity for every element and sides. Negative Jacobians are a common issue with a poor, usually externally generated, mesh.

commentnote

A fifth-order Gauss quadrature is used for this check. If you intend to use another quadrature, for example a higher order to integrate more accurately high order finite element variables, feel free to modify the generator for your needs.

Example input syntax: all diagnostics turned on

In this example, we examine a very basic mesh with all the diagnostics offered by the MeshDiagnosticsGenerator. This simple mesh presents no issue.

[Mesh]
  [base]
    type = GeneratedMeshGenerator
    dim = 2
    nx = 2
    ny = 2
  []
  [diag]
    type = MeshDiagnosticsGenerator
    input = base
    examine_element_overlap = WARNING
    examine_element_types = WARNING
    examine_element_volumes = WARNING
    examine_non_conformality = WARNING
    examine_nonplanar_sides = INFO
    examine_sidesets_orientation = WARNING
    search_for_adaptivity_nonconformality = WARNING
    check_local_jacobian = WARNING
  []
[]

[Outputs]
  exodus = true
[]
(moose/test/tests/meshgenerators/mesh_diagnostics_generator/all_at_once.i)

Input Parameters

  • inputThe mesh we want to diagnose

    C++ Type:MeshGeneratorName

    Controllable:No

    Description:The mesh we want to diagnose

Required Parameters

  • check_local_jacobianNO_CHECKwhether to check the local Jacobian for negative values

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to check the local Jacobian for negative values

  • examine_element_overlapNO_CHECKwhether to find overlapping elements

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to find overlapping elements

  • examine_element_typesNO_CHECKwhether to look for multiple element types in the same sub-domain

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to look for multiple element types in the same sub-domain

  • examine_element_volumesNO_CHECKwhether to examine volume of the elements

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to examine volume of the elements

  • examine_non_conformalityNO_CHECKwhether to examine the conformality of elements in the mesh

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to examine the conformality of elements in the mesh

  • examine_nonplanar_sidesNO_CHECKwhether to check element sides are planar

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to check element sides are planar

  • examine_sidesets_orientationNO_CHECKwhether to check that sidesets are consistently oriented using neighbor subdomains. If a sideset is inconsistently oriented within a subdomain, this will not be detected

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to check that sidesets are consistently oriented using neighbor subdomains. If a sideset is inconsistently oriented within a subdomain, this will not be detected

  • log_length_limit10How many problematic element/nodes/sides/etc are explicitly reported on by each check

    Default:10

    C++ Type:unsigned int

    Controllable:No

    Description:How many problematic element/nodes/sides/etc are explicitly reported on by each check

  • maximum_element_volumes1e+16Maximum size for element volume

    Default:1e+16

    C++ Type:double

    Controllable:No

    Description:Maximum size for element volume

  • minimum_element_volumes1e-16minimum size for element volume

    Default:1e-16

    C++ Type:double

    Controllable:No

    Description:minimum size for element volume

  • nonconformal_tol1e-06tolerance for element non-conformality

    Default:1e-06

    C++ Type:double

    Controllable:No

    Description:tolerance for element non-conformality

  • search_for_adaptivity_nonconformalityNO_CHECKwhether to check for non-conformality arising from adaptive mesh refinement

    Default:NO_CHECK

    C++ Type:MooseEnum

    Options:NO_CHECK, INFO, WARNING, ERROR

    Controllable:No

    Description:whether to check for non-conformality arising from adaptive mesh refinement

Optional Parameters

  • control_tagsAdds user-defined labels for accessing object parameters via control logic.

    C++ Type:std::vector<std::string>

    Controllable:No

    Description:Adds user-defined labels for accessing object parameters via control logic.

  • enableTrueSet the enabled status of the MooseObject.

    Default:True

    C++ Type:bool

    Controllable:No

    Description:Set the enabled status of the MooseObject.

  • save_with_nameKeep the mesh from this mesh generator in memory with the name specified

    C++ Type:std::string

    Controllable:No

    Description:Keep the mesh from this mesh generator in memory with the name specified

Advanced Parameters

  • nemesisFalseWhether or not to output the mesh file in the nemesisformat (only if output = true)

    Default:False

    C++ Type:bool

    Controllable:No

    Description:Whether or not to output the mesh file in the nemesisformat (only if output = true)

  • outputFalseWhether or not to output the mesh file after generating the mesh

    Default:False

    C++ Type:bool

    Controllable:No

    Description:Whether or not to output the mesh file after generating the mesh

  • show_infoFalseWhether or not to show mesh info after generating the mesh (bounding box, element types, sidesets, nodesets, subdomains, etc)

    Default:False

    C++ Type:bool

    Controllable:No

    Description:Whether or not to show mesh info after generating the mesh (bounding box, element types, sidesets, nodesets, subdomains, etc)

Debugging Parameters